The best way to test the usability of your web project depends on a number of different factors, with the amount of traffic playing the biggest part. If your web project is only recently up and running and you haven’t had many visitors as of yet, multivariate testing won’t provide you with reliable results on the success of each variant. In such a case, it is recommended to test the functionality of individual variables in consecutive A/B tests. If on the other hand, your web presence has high traffic, multivariate tests are the better option since you save time and effort.
A pre-requisite for both methods is that you have to have formulated clear hypotheses and result quantities for the tested elements. Otherwise, the test results will be difficult to interpret. In contrast to the usability analysis during the development process, you must also expect the conversion rate to deteriorate temporarily during this live test. So when it comes to testing out new ideas or variants, multivariate tests are neither efficient nor adequate, and A/B testing is often too limited. Preliminary experiments on a smaller scale and with clearly formulated questions are a much more effective and less risky solution.
If your web project has enough traffic and you decide to perform multivariate testing, you shouldn’t see this as a carte blanche to create as many variables or versions as possible. For an optimal result, it is advisable to proceed as strategically as possible and only have the main opponents compete against each other by pre-selecting which ones these are. In order to play it safe, you can even check the test result with a subsequent A/B test. However, you should be aware that using one of these testing methods doesn’t guarantee an increase in the conversion rate, but merely gives you ideas for what could increase it.