Many employees would love to be their own bosses. After all, it is a tempting prospect to manage one’s own working hours and no longer be dependent on the boss’s instructions. The feeling of working directly for yourself also makes it attractive to switch to self-employment. Some, on the other hand, do not opt for self-employment entirely voluntarily, but see it as the only way to get work.
In any case, both groups run the risk of being classed as falsely self-employed. Employers save on social security contributions and are not bound by labor laws if they employ freelancers. If they make use of these advantageous aspects of a working relationship, but otherwise have the essential characteristics of dependent employment, the legislator classifies these employees as falsely self-employed. But what is false self-employment? How can it be recognized? We answer these questions in the following sections.
False self-employment is not a legal term, but rather comes from colloquial language. In short, it is when a contractor is treated as self-employed but works under conditions similar to those of a permanent employee. This is also known as misclassification of an employee as an independent contractor. This can happen accidentally, but it can also be due to ignorance or unfair intent on the part of the employer.
If it turns out that a free contractual relationship between the client and the contractor is actually in a dependent employment relationship (i.e. essential criteria of false self-employment), then this has legal consequences for both sides – namely …
What constitutes dependent employment under labor and social law, i.e. whether there has been a misclassification of a worker, is generally dealt with in the Fair Labor Standards Act(FLSA) and is the purview of the US Department of Labor. The FLSA determines whether an employment relationship is contractual or based on “economic reality” rather than “technical concepts” and is not based on a master servant relationship. The US supreme court has also had a number of rulings, including the decision that there is no single test for deciding whether a person is self-employed or an employee. Instead, it’s the situation or total activity that dictates the classification. Significant factors include:
If the above mentioned framework conditions apply to an individual, they are not considered to be self-employed or a contractor, but bound by an employment contract and subsequently, an employee. However, the tolerated degree of this independence depends on the activity concerned – and only an overall view of all circumstances should clarify whether an employment contract exists. It is particularly important in this context that the nature and performance of the work and the dependence on the client are essential criteria by which the employment relationship is assessed. The existence of a contract formulated in writing is therefore less important than the actual working conditions for establishing the misclassification of an employee!
The relationship between an employer and its employees is governed by labor law. This law sets out the employee’s dependence on the employer in clear rules. In comparison, independent contractors and freelancers can organize their working relationships much more freely. However, if the independent contractor is largely dependent on the client to the same extent as a regular employee, then a misclassification as an independent contractor has occurred. According to labor law, if they fulfil the criteria listed in the previous section, then an employment contract actually exists, along with all legal consequences. This could mean concrete vacation requirements, dismissal protections, wage continuation guarantees in case of illness, and many other advantages for the contractor, depending on the labor laws in their state.
Whether you are being misclassified as an independent contractor under labor law and are entitled to an employment contract may be clarified by bringing a suit to the labor court.
In the US, employees are subject to federal and (sometimes) state taxes which employers are required to pay on behalf of their employees, and which must be paid by independent contractors themselves in annual filings. If you are being led to believe that you are a full employee when you are being misclassified as an independent contractor, your employer is not withholding these taxes from your wages and paying them on your behalf, which means you are not contributing to these taxes and may be accused of tax avoidance unwittingly.
Theoretically, any self-employment field could have individuals finding themselves misclassified as self-employed. However, in certain occupational groups this exploitation occurs more frequently. These include:
What criteria should you pay particular attention to if you are unsure whether you are a full employee or an independent contractor? In principle, there are some typical characteristics, even if much depends on the individual case. You can use the following checklist to see whether you are self-employed and how likely it is that an employment relationship will be classified as such. The following characteristics highlight that you may be falsely self-employed:
The following two examples illustrate to what extent the misclassification as self-employed can differ:
Being misclassified as an independent contractor has ramifications for your employment status, as well as your social security, Medicare, and federal and/or state tax payments.
Employers are responsible for paying social security, Medicare, and federal and/or state income taxes on behalf of their employees. If an employer misclassifies an employee, they are violating wage, tax, and employment eligibility laws. Doing so can incur fines and/or legal action from the US Department of Labor (DoL), the Internal Revenue System (IRS), as well as state agencies. Employers are also required to file payroll taxes and may be fined for failing to do so if they are misclassifying employees.
Additionally, employers must have I-9 forms on record for each individual employee to provide their employment eligibility. If you have misclassified an employee as an independent contractor, you may be fined for not retaining their I-9 forms on record.
Failure to pay for any fines or employee back-taxes, as well as being found to be deliberately misclassifying employees, may result in criminal or civil proceedings.
Aside from financial losses at the hands of the DoL, IRS, or state agencies for misclassifying employees, employers also open themselves up to the possibility of class-action lawsuits being brought against them by their employees. These can be lengthy and extremely expensive, as well as contribute to reputation damage and the loss of potential talent.
Click here for important legal disclaimers.
Regulations on working hours are one of the most important arrangements between an employee and employer. But how much break time are employees entitled to? How does the law define breaks and are there any exceptions? Which breaks are paid for and which aren’t? Answers to all these questions can be found in this article.
Would you like to work part-time as a self-employed person? You are not the only one. No wonder, as there are some advantages to owning a start-up, like minimizing your financial risk. Starting a part-time self-employed side gig is easy, but there are certain conditions to be observed. If you start your own business on a part-time basis, you will be faced with a number of considerations: How will...
Running your own business can be a challenge, as well as highly rewarding. Having to deal with paperwork often seems like a necessary evil, but preparing yourself for individual steps can help break it down. Registering your business need not be stressful – we’ve got a guide here on how to register your business to help you along the way!
Provide powerful and reliable service to your clients with a web hosting package from IONOS.
